Details |
Undue influence means some unfair and improper conduct, some coercion from
outside, some overreaching, some form of cheating and generally, though not
always, some personal advantage gained. The key element is that the
influence was so great that the testator, donor or party to the contract
had lost the ability to exercise his/her judgment and could not refuse to
give in to the pressure.
An agreement procured by the undue influence of one party is voidable at
the option of the other party. Undue influence includes any influence by
which the exercise of free and deliberate judgment is excluded. Undue
influence is presumed until the contrary is proved when the relation of the
parties is such that one is entitled to the confidential advice of the
other, as in the case of solicitor and client, of a trustee and his cestui
que trust, and of a parent contracting with a child who has just come of
age. In other cases of confidential relationship, the party seeking to
avoid a contract must prove undue influence. ….. [Sutton & Shannon on
Contracts, 6th Ed. p. 17B.]
Burden of proof lies in the first instance on the party who raises the plea
of undue influence. If that party proves that the other party was not only
in a position to dominate his will, but that the transaction entered into
was also unconscionable, then the burden of proof that he did not use his
dominant position to obtain an unfair advantage over the other is shifted
on to him. ….. [Srimati Bidhumukhi Bassaya vs. Srimati Sarala Sundari
Dassya & anr 6 DLR 97]
See, Section 16 of the Contract Act, 1872 (Act No. IX of 1872); Section
171C of the Penal Code, 1860; (XLV of 1860) the Representation of the
People Order, 1972 (P.O. 155 of 1972) art. 77.
|